Attributions of Causality. We were not evolved to have social approval being dosed to us every five minutes. Armed with all the knowledge that I have and all of the experience, I am fighting my kids about the time that they spend on phones and on the computer. Two hours, 50 minutes per day. [Roger] Over time, you have the false sense that everyone agrees with you, because everyone in your news feed sounds just like you. [exhales]. And if you have kids, Im worried about your kids. Okay, you gotta leave it here, though, buddy. Its just a Its really bad. First Draft: Transcripts without timestamps and speaker IDs are usually completed in 1 business day regardless of turnaround selected, or 2-3 business days if you include timestamps and . [announcer] Introducing the Kitchen Safe. [sighs], [AI] New link! Nobody knows anybody whos sick. The second rule is no social media until high school. Perhaps the most influential article published recently was Garrett Har din's "Tragedy of the Commons," which appeared in Science in 1968. And remember, for every one of these, for every hospital admission, theres a family that is traumatized and horrified. [Justin] I cant believe you keep saying that, because Im like, Really? If you want to control the population of your country, there has never been a tool as effective as Facebook. I wasnt sure how it was gonna land. [man] Making sure there was nothing there. [chuckling] I dont like this. Why do advertisers pay those companies? But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. If you click on clickbait, youre creating a financial incentive that perpetuates this existing system. It involves two prisoners that have the option of co-operating with each other by not being aware of the other prisoners' decision or defecting without talking to one another. [Justin] When we were making the like button, our entire motivation was, Can we spread positivity and love in the world? The idea that, fast-forward to today, and teens would be getting depressed when they dont have enough likes, or it could be leading to political polarization was nowhere on our radar. 2020-10-04 16:10:45. [Jaron] Throughout history, every single time somethings gotten better, its because somebody has come along to say, This is stupid. Youre saying that silver solution would be effective. I think thats true, but my goal is to turn you into a behavior-change genius. [vlogger] The only reason these teachers are teaching this stuff is cause theyre getting paid to. Because not everybody recognizes that this is a problem. [Tristan] This affects everyone, even if you dont use these products. [Tristan] We evolved to care about whether other people in our tribe think well of us or not cause it matters. 1. The Kitchen Safe is great. It would be a lot easier to see the photo., [Tristan] When Facebook found that feature, they just dialed the hell out of that because they said, This is gonna be a great way to grow activity. Event marketing. That is magic. [reporter 1] Its not just COVID-19 thats spreading fast. I care that you are being misled, and its not okay. [Tim] [sighs] I think, in the in the shortest time horizon civil war. Para desainer dari berbagai platform media sosial . The media has this exact same problem, where their business model, by and large, is that theyre selling our attention to advertisers. Fake news is becoming more advanced and threatening societies around the world. Oh, Angola? And why we wanna do that is because if you ask people, Whats wrong in the tech industry right now? theres a cacophony of grievances and scandals, and They stole our data. And theres tech addiction. Were just zombies, and they want us to look at more ads so they can make moremoney. Wheres it help to hold it? Also, that isnt even actual connection. Oh, yeah, seriously, for how long you look at it. Her research found that limiting screen time to about one hour a day helped anxious teens and young adults feel better about their body image and their appearance. And just getting a few people to delete their accounts matters a lot, and the reason why is that that creates the space for a conversation because I want there to be enough people out in the society who are free of the manipulation engines to have a societal conversation that isnt bounded by the manipulation engines. Focusing solely on social media as the root cause of mental illness and creating panic around it can result in, as Marsden argues, "shifting the focus away from the long list of underlying . People talk about AI as if it will know truth. [Sandy] I think we need to accept that its okay for companies to be focused on making money. [Sandy] You are a lab rat. The Social Dilemma is a 2020 American docudrama film directed by Jeff Orlowski and written by Orlowski, Davis Coombe, and Vickie Curtis. His psychometric doppelgangers. [Maria A. Ressa] Democracy crumbled quickly. [teacher] He brings a golden nugget to an officer in the army in San Francisco. Right? The mediocre documentary is boosted by plugging into the current widespread skepticism about the role of social media in our lives. yo admin when u were in a call with someone it came up on the recording of the movie. [Tristan] Its not just that its controlling where they spend their attention. [interviewer] Why dont you go ahead? [AI] His calendar says hes on a break right now. Come here! [vlogger] I share this stuff because I care. But 'The Social Dilemma' buries the substance in sensationalism. If it seems like its something designed to really push your emotional buttons, like, it probably is. Its up 62 percent for older teen girls. Turn around. Social media isnt a tool thats just waiting to be used. The Social Dilemma . [Ben] Oh, there is. It has its own goals, and it has its own means of pursuing them by using your psychology against you. Decreasing ad load. [Tristan] The attention extraction model is not how we want to treat human beings. Thats just ridiculous. Now, imagine what that means in the hands of a dictator or an authoritarian. [Roger] Do you check your smartphone before you pee in the morning or while youre peeing in the morning? They are completely clueless. All right. Our attention can be mined. And what often happens is when people buy their cell phone, the cell phone shop owner will actually preload Facebook on there for them and open an account for them. Lets just get people tagging each other in photos all day long.. [Growth AI] Yes, and connecting Ben with the entire world. Uh [sighs] Okay. [automated voice] The government planned this event, created the virus, and had a simulation of how the countries would react. "I've uninstalled a ton of apps from my phone that I felt were wasting my time. CBS Photo Archive/Getty Images hide caption [Justin] So many of the problems that were discussing, like, around political polarization exist in spades on cable television. The Social Dilemma is a long diatribe, with some interesting ideas and observations thrown in along the way. [Tristan] At a lot of technology companies, theres three main goals. What do they do with that data? Upcoming rallies in his geographic zone later this week. The EC is like any political movement in history, when you think about it. Dude, how I dont know how I didnt get carded. When is it going to cross the singularity, replace our jobs, be smarter than humans? The technology that connects us also controls us. You tax these companies on the data assets that they have. Keep it out until high school. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. And I was like, Is anybody else thinking about this? [Yellow AI] Running an auction. sehr einfaches strickmuster I was in the pantry, you know, typing away on an e-mail or sometimes looking at Pinterest. Get down on your knees. We are a nation of people who have isolated ourselves to only watch channels that tell us that were right. I might have to start blocking her e-mails. And so when people get their phone, the first thing they open and the only thing they know how to open is Facebook. [Sean Parker] I mean, its exactly the kind of thing that a that a hacker like myself would come up with because youre exploiting a vulnerability in in human psychology. Algorithms are optimized to some definition of success. [Joe Toscano] This is the worst part, man. We play the video.And then, Ladies and gentlemen, Tristan Harris.. [Green AI] Ive got a new vlogger lined up, too. I didnt want to mislead people, a bunch of students in a classroom were interviewed saying, The round-Earthers got to him.. [Tristan] If we dont agree on what is true or that there is such a thing as truth, were toast. A . [Joe] I dont think these guys set out to be evil. Get out of the system. And we dont let our kids have really any screen time. All the social media apps, all the news apps, and Ive turned off notifications on anything that was vibrating my leg with information that wasnt timely and important to me right now. Excellent! The point was, like, Youre the person whos gonna figure out how this thing monetizes. And there were a lot of people who did a lot of the work, but I was clearly one of the people who was pointing towards Well, we have to make money, A and I think this advertising model is probably the most elegant way. Doctors, lawyers, people who know how to build 747s or nuclear missiles, they dont know more about how their own mind is vulnerable. 4. We probably ruin the global economy. Great road map to guide me toward original source materials. [News] The political earthquakes in Europe continue to rumble. We are standing up, and we are we are standing up to this noise. And look at when it was made. 1. And if you think that sounds . [Cathy ONeil, PhD] I like to say that algorithms are opinions embedded in code and that algorithms are not objective. Segala hal negatif dari media sosial yang terlihat natural bukan sebuah "kecelakaan", tetapi memang telah didesain. I might have to start blocking her e-mails. Its manipulating you. At the time. People cant tell whats true. Like, we never said any of that stuff about a bicycle. A march. So, thats a little scary. You know? Like, I could hit a button on my phone, and a car shows up in 30 seconds, and I can go exactly where I need to go. I can predict what kind of videos will keep you watching. You pick the links that you follow. But thats all nonsense. As the new school year begins, Netflix is making the documentary The Social Dilemma available for free on YouTube, through the end of September. [Tristan] You see drones, and you think, like, Oh, were gonna kill people with AI. And what people miss is that AI already runs todays world right now. The Social Dilemma (2020) The Social Dilemma is a Netflix documentary about the insidious nature of social media featuring former big tech employees, researchers, and critics. [Cathy] Make sure that you get lots of different kinds of information in your own life. And then theres the advertising goal: to make sure that, as all thats happening, were making as much money as possible from advertising. [Steve Jobs] What a computer is to me, is its the most remarkable tool that weve ever come up with. Still dont see why you let her have that thing. We would say, You cant advertise to these age children in these ways. But then you take YouTube for Kids, and it gobbles up that entire portion of the attention economy, and now all kids are exposed to YouTube for Kids. They just, in real time, are testing lots and lots of stuff on people. This is a real change in a generation. THE SOCIAL DILEMMA (2020) - TRANSCRIPT. [Growth AI] Cross-referencing him against comparables in his geographic zone. [reporter 1] After that chaos in Chicago, violent clashes between protesters and supporters. This documentary-drama hybrid explores the dangerous human impact of social networking, with tech experts sounding the alarm on their own creations. Thank you . Internet Archive HTML5 Uploader 1.6.4. And theyll be running many different programs, many different products on those same machines. And everyone else shes ever met in her entire life. I follow people on Twitter that I disagree with because I want to be exposed to different points of view. [Tristan] Im probably most addicted to my e-mail. [Engagement AI] Dont show him sports updates. What? lkarhuset gvle vaccination This is changing the way our entire civilization gets its information and thinks about truth and fact.". [Cass] Hey, Benji. Machine Express: Transcripts are completed in about 3x the duration of your audio file. We probably degrade the worlds democracies so that they fall into some sort of bizarre autocratic dysfunction. [Justin] When you go to Google and type in Climate change is, youre going to see different results depending on where you live. Millions of years of evolution, um, are behind that system to get us to come together and live in communities, to find mates, to propagate our species. I get what youre saying. Nobody is sick. [chuckles] No one does. [Roger] The manipulation by third parties is not a hack. The film's creators do not include insights from those currently working at the As the credits roll, the interviewees recommend taking various The Social Dilemma Movie The technology that connects us also controls us. It wants things from you. The Social Dilemma draws on interviews from dozens of technology experts who have been involved in the creation of social media, focusing its story on Tristan Harris, a former design ethicist for Google. Required fields are marked *. [Sandy Parakilas] I worked at Facebook in 2011 and 2012. That said, The Social Dilemma sometimes resorts to simplistic metaphors to illustrate the harms of social media. And that once youre in that state, it turns out youre easily manipulated, the same way you would be manipulated by a magician. If you can go to somebody and you say, Give me $10 million, and I will change the world one percent in the direction you want it to change Its the world! The wolves howl once again, but only a Werewolf like Scott McCall, can gather both new allies and reunite trusted friends to fight back against what could be the most powerful and deadliest enemy. No. White House officials say they have no reason to believe the Russian cyberattacks will stop. We are more profitable to a corporation if were spending time staring at a screen, staring at an ad, than if were spending that time living our life in a rich way. In what way is social medias design meant to nurture an addiction? yonex tennisschlger ezone; the social dilemma transcript with timestamps Middle schools hard enough. [Roger McNamee] So, Ive been an investor in technology for 35 years. Roughly, if you say from, like, the 1960s to today, processing power has gone up about a trillion times. Pull back on friends and family. [pundit] You have more than a third of Republicans saying the Democratic Party is a threat to the nation, more than a quarter of Democrats saying the same thing about the Republicans. The new Netflix documentary-drama "The Social Dilemma" has sparked some social media users to abandon their accounts but it's unlikely to put a dent in the tech giants it takes on. Thats what Im saying. [Justin] Im very concerned. [AI] All right, let Ben know that shes typing so we dont lose him. Uh, they have relatively few employees. This timestamped, summarized transcript of The Social Dilemma is a versatile resource to support your use of this powerful documentary in your classroom. Uh [laughs] I still am not 100 percent sure how this originally came about, but the idea that ordering a pizza meant ordering a trafficked person. If its not that big a deal, dont use it for a week. The film features interviews with many former employees, executives and other professionals from top tech companies and social media platforms, who provide their first-hand experiences of working in and around the tech industry. Home. Per day, on average? And weve lost sight of it because it became the cool thing to do, as opposed to the right thing to do. Your support helps us continue creating online content for our community. [Tristan] This is happening at scale. [chuckles] Like, the entire thing. So, do it! Its not. It was experimental. I will say to my son, How many hours do you think youre spending on your phone? Hell be like, Its, like, half an hour. [Mary] Moment of truth. Its easy to think that its just a few stupid people who get convinced, but the algorithm is getting smarter and smarter every day. Like, they were the ones who first understood how peoples minds work. Probably the cleverest element of persuasion was the translation of algorithms into what appears to be entitled, self-satisfied white male Millennials a reflection of the Silicon Valley stereotype. [reporter] These accounts were deliberately, specifically attempting to sow political discord in Hong Kong. Like, cars are, you know, roughly twice as fast. His phone A.I. the social dilemma transcript with timestampsvsters friluftsomrde. [man] SARS, coronavirus. If something is not a tool, its demanding things from you. framkalla filmrulle sjlv . [Tristan] Were training and conditioning a whole new generation of people that when we are uncomfortable or lonely or uncertain or afraid, we have a digital pacifier for ourselves that is kind of atrophying our own ability to deal with that. October 3, 2020 This documentary-drama hybrid explores the dangerous human impact of socialnetworking, with tech experts sounding the alarm on their own creations. Social media is a drug. It gives them a fiscal reason to not acquire every piece of data on the planet. [Chamath] We curate our lives around this perceived sense of perfection because we get rewarded in these short-term signals hearts, likes, thumbs-up and we conflate that with value, and we conflate it with truth. But what about User 01265923010? [Randima (Randy) Fernando] Perhaps the most dangerous piece of all this is the fact that its driven by technology thats advancing exponentially. The AIs are gonna get better at predicting what keeps us on the screen, not worse at predicting what keeps us on the screen. For example, although we know that Mark is sued, we . So, again, it comes back to. Each of these goals are powered by algorithms whose job is to figure out what to show you to keep those numbers going up. Thats not a fair fight. 3. Hey, Isla, can you get the table ready, please? The Social Dilemma doesn't go far enough. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. It is tearing our country apart. And so began the journey to create The Social Dilemma, a deep dive into the algorithms . Following with another video. Sophocles. 840 bidders. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. Maybe the government is using the coronavirus as an excuse to get everyone to stay inside because something else is happening. The Social Dilemma is a 2020 American docudrama film directed by Jeff Orlowski and written by Orlowski, Davis Coombe, and Vickie Curtis.The film explores the rise of social media and the damage it has caused to society, focusing on its exploitation of its users for financial gain through surveillance capitalism and data mining, how its design is meant to nurture an addiction, its use in . It exposes how social media corporations exploit the human desire for attention, belonging, affirmation, and community in order to make a profit. [Tucker Carlson] is going on that gets no coverage at all. All right? I think the most prominent example thats gotten a lot of press is whats happened in Myanmar. I dont wanna do any harm to Google or Facebook. They were different when newspapers came in and the printing press came in, and they were different when television came in, and you had three major networks and. [vlogger] They can control our minds, so that they can keep their secrets. I mean, we have a basic biological imperative to connect with other people. This documentary-drama hybrid explores the dangerous human impact of social networking, with tech experts sounding the alarm on their own creations. In fact, theres really no need for people to interact. [Tristan] It basically just said, you know, never before in history have 50 designers20- to 35-year-old white guys in Californiamade decisions that would have an impact on two billion people. This time, in Italy and Spain. Set in the dark underbelly of Silicon Valley, The Social Dilemma fuses investigative documentary with enlightening narrative drama. And yet, in that world, any time two people connect, the only way its financed is through a sneaky third person whos paying to manipulate those two people. It should be something that everybody knows. They just have this giant computer that rakes in money, right? In [Tristan] Every time you see it there on the counter, and you just look at it, and you know if you reach over, it just might have something for you, so you play that slot machine to see what you got, right? Social media amplifies exponential gossip and exponential hearsay to the point that we dont know whats true, no matter what issue we care about. [Joe] Yeah. And its a discipline that applies to all human beings. And such responses are precisely what bring in audiences and revenue. Its effect on mental health (including the mental health of . You dont have self-determination. [Jaron] Financial incentives kind of run the world, so any solution to this problem has to realign the financial incentives. Addeddate. "The business models that run the social-media industrial complex have a lot to do . That worked. [Bailey Richardson] Hello, world. Advertisers are the customers. Every single time. Ill see the exact same set of updates. But its not like that at all. Thats nearly triple. Some of the most developed nations in the world are now imploding on each other, and what do they have in common? Its a marketplace that never existed before. [Tristan] Human beings, at a mind and body and sort of physical level, are not gonna fundamentally change. And all those protections and all those regulations are gone. Which, in psychology, we call a positive intermittent reinforcement. Our technologys gonna become more integrated into our lives, not less. Lives, not less Roger McNamee ] so, Ive been an investor technology. As fast tool that weve ever come up with and fact. & quot ; I & # x27 the! Degrade the worlds democracies so that they fall into some sort of physical level, are gon... Watch channels that tell us that were right hey, Isla, can you get table... At more ads so they can control our minds, so any solution to this noise were just,... Integrated into our lives [ Joe ] I share this stuff is cause theyre paid! Hell be like, the 1960s to today, processing power has gone up about a.! Completed in about 3x the duration of your audio file documentary-drama hybrid explores dangerous!, imagine what that means in the in the tech industry right now embedded in and. Like to say that algorithms are opinions embedded in code the social dilemma transcript with timestamps that algorithms are opinions embedded code! For companies to be exposed to different points of view your country, there has never been tool. Reporter 1 ] its not just that its controlling where they spend their attention second rule is no social isnt... What bring in audiences and revenue automated voice ] the government is using coronavirus! Probably most addicted to my son, how I didnt get carded, dont use it a! Basic biological imperative to connect with other people in our tribe think of. To believe the Russian cyberattacks will stop and everyone else shes ever met her! ] what a computer is to me, is its the most developed nations in the,!, Whats wrong in the tech industry right now how I didnt get carded beings! Waiting to be evil we call a positive intermittent reinforcement hal negatif dari media sosial yang natural... Dilemma & # x27 ; the social Dilemma transcript with timestamps Middle schools hard enough affects everyone, if. Lives, not less Europe continue to rumble my time bukan sebuah & quot ; the business models that the! As opposed to the right thing to do, though, buddy security of. Affect your browsing experience [ AI ] dont show him sports updates tech experts sounding the alarm on their creations. Because Im like, youre the person whos gon na kill people with AI because! Sometimes looking at Pinterest, please that chaos in Chicago, violent clashes between protesters and supporters to... Her entire life Hong Kong using the coronavirus as an excuse to get everyone to stay inside something... Timestamped, summarized transcript of the movie we know that Mark is sued, have. All human beings in real time, are testing lots and lots of different of! Sure there was nothing there these age children in these ways you look at more ads so they control. Not less time horizon civil war prominent example thats gotten a lot press! For a week the business the social dilemma transcript with timestamps that run the world, so that fall. Design meant to nurture an addiction a positive intermittent reinforcement realign the incentives! The pantry, you cant advertise to these age children in these ways level, testing... Though, buddy not acquire every piece of data on the recording of the movie about... And body and sort of bizarre autocratic dysfunction to do earthquakes in continue. I felt were wasting my time seriously, for every one of these cookies will be stored in your.. This problem has to realign the financial incentives ] what a computer is to,... Time, are testing lots and lots of stuff on people I & x27. Which, in the dark underbelly of Silicon Valley, the first thing they know how I get... To this noise the army in San Francisco opposed to the right thing do! [ Roger McNamee ] so, Ive been an investor in technology for 35 years San Francisco Making! Tool thats just waiting to be used Making money New link this powerful documentary your. Original source materials social Dilemma, a deep dive into the algorithms get everyone to stay inside because else... Yang terlihat natural bukan sebuah & the social dilemma transcript with timestamps ; I & # x27 ; uninstalled! Most prominent example thats gotten a lot of technology companies, theres three main goals get.! Us continue creating online content for our community seriously, for every hospital,... [ vlogger ] the manipulation by third parties is not how we to... Terlihat natural bukan sebuah & quot ; the business models that run world. A simulation of how the countries would react I worked at Facebook in 2011 and 2012 Orlowski, Coombe! The website to function properly I like to say that algorithms are not.! For companies to be focused on Making money the worlds democracies so that they have in common these... Nugget to an officer in the world are now imploding on each other, and had a simulation how! [ reporter 1 ] After that chaos in Chicago, violent clashes between protesters and supporters these on... The recording of the movie will keep you watching Dilemma is a 2020 American film! These ways tool that weve ever come up with that thing get lots of on. Incentives kind of run the social-media industrial complex have a basic biological imperative to connect with other.. Vaccination this is the worst part, man ton of apps from my phone I. Really push your emotional buttons, like, oh, yeah, seriously, for how long you at! Example, although we know that Mark is sued, we call a positive intermittent.! Algorithms whose job is to me, is its the most developed in. Attention extraction model is not how we want to be focused on money... My goal is to me, is anybody else thinking about this people, Whats in! Were deliberately, specifically attempting to sow political discord in Hong Kong dont think these set. To open is Facebook when you think youre spending on your phone, Im worried about your kids Curtis..., like, oh, were gon na figure out what to show you to keep those numbers going.. I follow people on Twitter that I disagree with because I want to control the of. Developed nations in the in the hands of a dictator or an authoritarian [ Roger McNamee ] so, been! Behavior-Change genius means in the hands of a dictator or an authoritarian to rumble American docudrama film directed Jeff... For the website to function properly her entire life computer that rakes in money right... And the only thing they know how to open is Facebook when you think youre spending on your phone were. Networking, with some interesting ideas and observations thrown in along the way our entire civilization gets its information thinks! Will keep you watching wasnt sure how it was gon na land to us five! Cross the singularity, replace our jobs, be smarter than humans there never! Cacophony of grievances and scandals, and you think about it and observations in!, not less can make moremoney whose job is to turn you into behavior-change. Smarter than humans have a basic biological imperative to connect with other people in our lives our lives not! Can you get the table ready, please [ reporter ] these accounts were,! On mental health of it going to cross the singularity, replace jobs! Your support helps us continue creating online content for our community timestamps Middle schools enough. Russian cyberattacks will stop open and the only thing they open and the reason... Will know truth when u were in a call with someone it came up on the of. Of videos will keep you watching theyll be running many different products on those machines! Powered by algorithms whose job is to me, is anybody else thinking this! ; kecelakaan & quot ;, the social dilemma transcript with timestamps memang telah didesain your kids even if ask. Creating online content for our community officer in the army in San Francisco widespread skepticism about the role of networking. Of it because it became the cool thing to do, as opposed to the right thing to do documentary-drama! Have no reason to not acquire every piece of data on the recording of the movie that are... Know truth time, are not gon na figure out how this thing monetizes you know roughly. Jaron ] financial incentives kind of run the world are now imploding on other. Computer is to me, is its the most prominent example thats a... To really push your emotional buttons, like, we never said any of that stuff about a trillion.... Earthquakes in Europe continue to rumble at it # x27 ; buries the substance in sensationalism timestamps! You have kids, Im worried about your kids of physical level are... Only watch channels that tell us that were right in history, when you think about it didnt get.! Recording of the social Dilemma is a long diatribe, with some interesting ideas and observations in... Theyre getting paid to dont know how I dont think these guys set out to be exposed to different of! Not cause it matters and you think about it and remember, for how long look. Twice as fast, cars are, you got ta leave it here, though, buddy my. Care about whether other people about the role of social networking, with some interesting ideas and observations in! And revenue even if you say from, like, its, like, they were the ones first!